Apple AirTag
Status: KEEPThe lost-keys tax, canceled, if you live on iPhone; the finding network is the product.
The catch: iPhone only in practice; needs a holder for keys.
Added 2026-08 · Checked 2026-08
iPhone: AirTag, no debate, the network wins. Android: Tile Pro or a Chipolo on Google's Find network. And the $8 key bowl by the door beats all of them within two weeks; buy both, the tracker covers the gap.
Some links here earn us a commission, including Amazon links. Commissions never decide what gets a stamp. How the shelf works → The money detail.
| Item | Stamp | Band | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|
| Apple AirTag | KEEP | $ (single) | iPhone households |
| Tile Pro | WORTH A LOOK | $$ | Android and mixed households |
| Chipolo POINT | WORTH A LOOK | $ | The loudest ring |
| A bowl by the door | KEEP | $ | Beating the problem entirely |
No. 1
The lost-keys tax, canceled, if you live on iPhone; the finding network is the product.
The catch: iPhone only in practice; needs a holder for keys.
Added 2026-08 · Checked 2026-08
Best for: iPhone households
No. 2
The cross-platform tracker; Android households start here.
The catch: Network density trails Apple's, and a subscription upsell exists.
Added 2026-08 · Checked 2026-08
Best for: Android and mixed households
No. 3
Loudest ring of the trackers and plays nicely with Google's Find network.
The catch: Same network-density caveat as all non-Apple trackers.
Added 2026-08 · Checked 2026-08
Best for: The loudest ring
No. 4
The $8 fix that beats every tracker: one bowl, by the door, keys live there.
The catch: The habit takes two weeks; the tracker covers the gap.
Added 2026-08 · Checked 2026-08
Best for: Beating the problem entirely
A tracker with no finding network only works inside the room you already searched.
Added 2026-08 · Checked 2026-08 · Returned 2026-08 · No network, no finding
Network density is the entire product. A tracker that only pings within Bluetooth range tells you what you already knew: the keys are somewhere in this room.
Stamps are earned per the desk's criteria: KEEP means still in use after 30 days or more, WORTH A LOOK means real merit with a situational fit. This list is re-checked quarterly and the table above carries the date. Nothing here paid to be listed, and the returned entry explains itself.